Snow slides off
Smooth metal panels shed snow loads that sit on asphalt shingles for weeks. Less standing snow means less meltwater refreezing at your eaves, which means dramatically less ice dam formation.

Built for lake-effect snow, freeze-thaw winters, and the long haul.
There is a reason metal roofs keep showing up on Central New York homes: they shed our snow instead of holding it, they shrug off the freeze-thaw cycling that ages asphalt, and they are often the last roof a homeowner ever buys.
Hometown Exteriors installs metal roofing built for exactly this climate, and we will tell you honestly whether it is the right call for your house.
Panel and finish samples brought to your estimate.
Syracuse sees roughly 120 inches of snow in an average winter and dozens of freeze-thaw swings. Those two facts drive most of the roofing problems in this region — and they are precisely the problems metal addresses:
Smooth metal panels shed snow loads that sit on asphalt shingles for weeks. Less standing snow means less meltwater refreezing at your eaves, which means dramatically less ice dam formation.
Asphalt ages by losing granules and flexibility through thermal cycling. Metal panels expand and contract as engineered, on concealed fasteners designed for the movement.
A properly installed metal roof is generally expected to last 40 to 70 years depending on panel type and finish, versus a typical 15 to 25 years for asphalt in this climate.
Interlocked standing seam panels handle the gusts that lift and crease shingle tabs. The tradeoff is upfront cost: metal typically runs two to three times the installed price of asphalt.
Standing seam (concealed fastener). Panels lock together at raised seams and the fasteners are hidden under the panel, never exposed to weather. The panels can move with thermal expansion, there are no fastener gaskets to age out, and the result is the metal roof that earns the multi-decade reputation. This is what we recommend for most CNY homes.
Exposed fastener (screw-down) panels. Lower cost, faster install, and a legitimate choice for garages, barns, and outbuildings. The screws penetrate the panel face through rubber washers, and those washers are the system's clock: they weather, back out with thermal movement, and need periodic re-tightening or replacement to stay sealed.
We will quote you the option that fits the building, and explain why.
We install both, so we have no horse in this race.
| Factor | Metal (standing seam) | Asphalt shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Expected service life | 40 to 70 years | 15 to 25 years in CNY |
| Upfront cost | Roughly 2 to 3 times asphalt | Lower |
| Snow and ice dams | Sheds snow, far fewer dams | Holds snow at the eaves |
| Maintenance | Minimal | Periodic repairs as it ages |
| Look | Modern or farmhouse panel lines | Traditional, more color/texture options |
| Repair after damage | Panel replacement, specialist work | Simple, any roofer can patch |
If you plan to be in the house ten years or less, asphalt usually wins the math; see our asphalt shingle roofing page. If this is the long-term home, metal's per-year cost is often the cheaper roof.
A metal roof is only as good as what is under and around it. Our installations include full deck inspection (soft decking gets replaced, not covered), ice and water barrier at eaves and valleys as NY code requires, underlayment rated for metal systems, and trim and flashing formed for the panel profile. Ventilation gets evaluated as part of the job: metal changes the roof's thermal behavior and the attic system should match it.
Two questions worth asking any metal installer: what gauge and finish are the panels (thicker panels and PVDF finishes resist denting and fading better), and how are penetrations flashed (pipe and vent flashing designed for panel movement, not caulk).
Snow guards. A roof that sheds 120 inches of snow per winter sheds it onto something: walkways, decks, gas meters, gutters, shrubs, parked cars. Snow guards release snow gradually instead of in one roof-length avalanche. They are not optional decoration in this region; placement gets engineered into the panel layout over doorways, walkways, and anything below the eave you care about.
Gutters that can take the winter. Sliding snow is hard on gutter systems, so hanger strength and placement relative to the panel edge get planned, not improvised. We size and mount gutter systems for metal roofs as part of the installation, not as an afterthought.
It is also worth saying what metal does in summer: light-colored and reflective finishes reject solar heat that asphalt absorbs, which CNY homeowners notice in second-floor bedrooms during July.
We install metal roofing across Onondaga County, including Syracuse, Clay, Cicero, Liverpool, Baldwinsville, Brewerton, Fayetteville, Manlius, and Marcellus, plus Chittenango in Madison County.
Get a free, no-obligation estimate from Central New York's trusted roofing & gutter experts.