The Syracuse-area freeze-thaw cycle is genuinely brutal on roofing. A small flashing gap or a lifted shingle that would sit harmlessly for three years on a mild coastal roof will turn into a $2,000 interior repair after two Central New York winters. Water gets in, freezes, expands, and pries the failure open a little more with every cycle.
Clogged gutters going into November are the other big compounding factor. When gutters can't drain, meltwater backs up under the shingles at the eave, and that's the classic recipe for the ice dams we spend every January dealing with. A plan visit in October catches both problems before winter locks them in.
The math on annual maintenance is straightforward. A caught-early repair on a plan visit costs the included allowance, or a small overage. The same problem left two winters becomes a leak repair with interior drywall and insulation work attached — routinely five to ten times the cost.